Tsallake zuwa babban abun ciki

Proton Pass vs Bitwarden (2026): Kwatance ta Gaskiya — Tsaro, Fasaloli, Farashi

Proton Pass da Bitwarden su ne masu sarrafa kalmomin shiga masu karfi biyu da suke ba da fifikon sirri. Dukansu buɗe tushe ne kuma ana ɓoye su daga ƙarshe zuwa ƙarshe. Ga wanda ya yi nasara akan tsaro, fasaloli, farashi, da wanda ya kamata ya zaɓi wanne — ba tare da ruɗi ba.

An sabunta shi: 21 Afirilu, 2026

Taƙaitaccen bayani

  • Dukansu buɗe tushe ne, ɓoye daga ƙarshe zuwa ƙarshe, kuma an yi musu binciken waje — kowannensu zaɓi ne mai ƙarfi.
  • **Bitwarden ya yi nasara akan farashi** — matsayinsa na kyauta ya rufe kalmomin shiga marasa iyaka, na'urori, da hosting na kai; Proton Pass kyauta ya iyakance ka ga vaults 10 da babu 2FA.
  • **Proton Pass ya yi nasara akan haɗin kai** — idan ka riga ka yi amfani da Proton Mail/VPN/Drive, an haɗa shi cikin asusu ɗaya tare da rufaffen alamun email da labarin farfadowa da aka raba.
  • **Proton Pass yana da alamun email da aka gina a ciki** (irin Hide-My-Email), an haɗa shi kyauta; Bitwarden yana buƙatar ƙari mai biyan kuɗi (Bitwarden Authenticator / SimpleLogin integration).
  • Dukansu suna ba da tsare-tsaren kasuwanci/ƙungiya; Bitwarden ya fi girma a can (SSO, sarrafa masu amfani, SCIM).

Amsar gajeren

Idan kuna yanke shawara tsakanin Proton Pass da Bitwarden a 2026, kuna zaɓar tsakanin masu sarrafa kalmomin shiga guda biyu da suke samun tushen abubuwan daidai — ɓoyewa daga ƙarshe zuwa ƙarshe, lambar tushe buɗe, bincike na ainihi na waje, da babu tsarin kasuwanci da aka tallafa da talla. Ko wanne zai kiyaye kalmomin shigar ku cikin aminci fiye da ajiyar na'ura mai zaman kanta, kuma ko wanne ya fi kyau da yawa fiye da sake yin amfani da kalmomin shiga 5 iri ɗaya akan shafuka 200.

Don haka wanda ya yanke shawara ba "wanne ya fi tsaro" ba — dukansu masu ƙarfi ne. Shi ne wanne ya dace da rayuwar ku:

  • Zaɓi Bitwarden idan: kuna son mafi kyawun matsayi na kyauta da ake samu a ko'ina, kuna kula da hosting na kai, ko kuna jin daɗi ba tare da alamun email da aka gina a ciki ba.
  • Zaɓi Proton Pass idan: ka riga ka yi amfani da Proton Mail/VPN/Drive, kana son alamun email rufaffen da aka gina a ciki, ko ka fi son app mai kyau fiye da adadin fasaloli ɗin.

Sauran wannan labarin shine kwatancen dalla-dalla — tsarin tsaro, farashi, fasaloli, goyan bayan dandamali, da al'amuran gefe — don haka za ku iya yin kira tare da cikakken mahallin.

Tsaro da ɓoyewa

Dukansu Proton Pass da Bitwarden suna aiwatar da tsarin cryptographic iri ɗaya: kalmar sirrin ku ba ta bar na'urarku. Ana wucewa ta hanyar aikin samo mabuɗi (KDF) don samar da mabuɗin vault, kuma kowane abu a cikin vault ɗin ku — kalmar shiga, bayanin kula, katin credit, sirrin TOTP — ana ɓoye shi da wannan mabuɗin ta amfani da AES-256 (musamman AES-256-GCM don Bitwarden, irin yanayin authenticated-encryption mai kama don Proton Pass). Ana upload ɓoyayyun blobs zuwa servers, waɗanda za su iya ajiyewa da daidaitawa amma ba za su iya buɗe komai ba.

Bambance-bambancen aiki:

Bitwarden ya fara amfani da PBKDF2 tare da maimaitawa 600,000 — KDF mai ƙarfi, wanda hukumomin ma'auni suka yi. Zaku iya canzawa zuwa Argon2id a cikin Saitunan Tsaro idan kuna son kariya mai ƙarfi na memory-hard akan harin brute-force na tushen GPU. Suna buga cikakken takarda: bitwarden.com/help/bitwarden-security-white-paper.

Proton Pass yana amfani da Argon2id ta hanyar ƙira — mai ƙarfin ƙwaƙwalwar ajiya mai cin nasara na Gasar Ɓoyewar Kalmar Shiga ta 2015 kuma galibi ana ɗaukarsa mafi tsayin daka ga brute-force fiye da PBKDF2. Takardun su na fasaha suna zaune a proton.me/blog/pass-security-model.

Dukansu an yi musu bincike na waje: Binciken Bitwarden na baya-bayan nan ya kasance ta Cure53 a 2023; Proton Pass ya yi bincike ta Securitum, kuma a 2023. Rahoton binciken jama'a ne.

Mai nasara: Dukansu masu tsaro ne na samarwa. Idan kuna son mafi kyawun KDF na ilimin ka'ida daga akwatin, Proton Pass's Argon2id default ya yi ɗan gaba — amma kowane Bitwarden na zamani da ya yi amfani da zaɓinsa na Argon2id ya yi daidai.

Farashi

Wannan shi ne inda dukansu suka bambanta sosai.

Bitwarden

  • Kyauta: abubuwan vault marasa iyaka, na'urori marasa iyaka, hosting na kai kyauta, manyan fayiloli da aka raba (har zuwa masu amfani 2). Matsayin kyauta yana aiki na gaske ga 95% na masu amfani.
  • Premium ($10/shekara): ya ƙara ajiyar lambar 2FA da aka gina a ciki (TOTP), abubuwan da aka makala har zuwa 1 GB, samun gaggawa, rahoton tsaro, da fifikon tallafi.
  • Iyalai ($40/shekara don masu amfani 6): Fasalolin Premium don ƙungiyar iyali.
  • Ƙungiyoyi/Masana'anta ($3-$6/mai amfani/wata): SSO, SCIM provisioning, ci-gaban log audit.

Proton Pass

  • Kyauta: abubuwan vault 10 gaba ɗaya, na'urori marasa iyaka, samar da kalmar shiga na asali. Iyakar abu 10 ta sa bai dace ga duk wanda ke da fiye da manyan asusu kaɗan ba.
  • Plus ($4.99/wata, $36/shekara ko an haɗa kyauta tare da Proton Unlimited a $12.99/wata): abubuwa marasa iyaka, alamun email marasa iyaka, 2FA da aka gina a ciki, hanyoyin tsaro don rabawa, vaults da aka raba har zuwa masu amfani 10.
  • Kasuwanci ($7.99/mai amfani/wata): sarrafa ƙungiya, vaults da aka raba, hanyar SSO.

Mai nasara: Bitwarden ga masu amfani da iyalai da suke kula da farashi. Proton Pass yana zama mai gasa ne kawai idan ka riga ka biyan Proton Unlimited — a wannan yanayin Pass yana zama kyauta a zahiri.

Fasaloli kai-da-kai

Fasalin Proton Pass Bitwarden
Abubuwan vault marasa iyaka ✅ (Plus kawai) ✅ (Kyauta)
Na'urori marasa iyaka ✅ ✅
Ɓoyewa daga ƙarshe zuwa ƙarshe ✅ ✅
Abokan ciniki buɗe tushe ✅ ✅
Server buɗe tushe ❌ (mai hosting kawai) ✅
Hosting na kai ❌ ✅
Ajiyar 2FA da aka gina a ciki (TOTP) ✅ (Plus) ✅ (Premium)
Alamun email ✅ (Plus, an haɗa) ❌ (haɗin ɓangare na uku)
Goyan bayan passkey ✅ ✅
Shiga ba tare da kalma ba (ta hanyar Proton Sentinel / Bitwarden Send) ✅ ✅
Vaults da aka raba ✅ (Plus, har zuwa masu amfani 10) ✅ (Iyalai/Ƙungiyoyi)
Raba kalmar shiga mai tsaro ✅ ✅
Sa ido kan yanar gizo mai duhu ✅ (Plus) ✅ (Premium)
Abubuwan da aka makala ❌ ✅ (Premium, 1 GB)
Samun gaggawa ❌ ✅ (Premium)
CLI ❌ ✅
Buɗe biometric ✅ ✅
Tsarin iyali ✅ (ta hanyar Proton Family) ✅ ($40/shekara, masu amfani 6)
Log audit / monitor breach ✅ ✅

Ikon alamun-email

Wannan shi ne mafi kyawun fasalin Proton Pass guda ɗaya. Lokacin da kuke yi rajista don sabbin sabis, Proton Pass na iya samar da alamar sau ɗaya kamar wk9m7n3@passinbox.com da ke turawa zuwa ainihin email ɗin ku. Zaku iya kashe alamar kowane lokaci (spam, keta, kamfani da ba ku amince da shi ba), kuma ainihin adireshi ya kasance a ɓoye. A kan Proton Unlimited kuna samun alamun marasa iyaka; Pass Plus yana ba ku 10.

Bitwarden yana da haɗin kai tare da SimpleLogin, addy.io, Firefox Relay, da Fastmail da ke samun abu iri ɗaya — amma kuna buƙatar asusu daban tare da kowannen. Proton ya haɗa shi a zahiri.

Idan alamar email / email-burner workflow yana da mahimmanci a gare ku (kuma ya kamata, don sirri), Proton Pass ya ci wannan rukuni gaba ɗaya.

Ikon hosting na kai

Wannan shi ne mafi kyawun fasalin Bitwarden guda ɗaya. Zaku iya gudanar da cikakken server na Bitwarden akan Raspberry Pi, cloud VPS, ko homelab ɗin ku. Rufaffun vault ɗin ku ba ya taɓa servers na Bitwarden. Ga masu maximalists na sirri, sysadmins, da duk wanda manufar kamfaninsa ta hana ajiyar cloud na ɓangare na uku na shaida, wannan ya yi yanke shawara.

Proton Pass mai hosting kawai ne. Proton yana sarrafa servers a Switzerland, sun kasance E2E-encrypted, kuma dokar Switzerland tana da kariya mai ƙarfi na sirri — amma har yanzu ɓangare na uku ne.

Apps da goyan bayan browser

Dukansu sun rufe manyan dandamali:

  • Apps desktop na Windows, macOS, Linux: dukansu.
  • Apps mobile na iOS da Android: dukansu, tare da buɗe biometric da haɗin auto-fill.
  • Extensions browser: dukansu suna jigilar don Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Safari, Brave, Opera.
  • CLI: Bitwarden kawai.
  • Apps agogo (Apple Watch): dukansu, karanta kawai.

A amfani na yau da kullun, dukansu auto-fill da auto-save suna aiki da dogaro. Ga labari, extension na Firefox na Bitwarden ya kasance mafi gwajin yaƙi na tsawon lokaci; UX na Proton Pass ya fi girma a zahiri a cikin apps mobile kuma yana jin kamar an tsara shi bayan-2022 (wanda shi ne).

Sirri da ikon shari'a

Proton Pass Proton AG ke sarrafa shi a Switzerland. Dokar sirri ta Switzerland (musamman Federal Act on Data Protection) tana cikin mafi ƙarfi a duniya, kuma Proton yana da dogon tarihi na buga rahoton bayyana gaskiya. Ana yin binciken Proton ta kamfanoni na waje akai-akai.

Bitwarden Bitwarden Inc. ke sarrafa shi a Amurka, musamman a Florida. Dokar sirri ta Amurka ta fi raunana fiye da dokar Switzerland, amma ɓoyewar E2E na Bitwarden yana nufin ko da buƙatar bayanai ta kotun Amurka ta ba da rufaffun ciphertext kawai. Tushen Bitwarden yana samuwa a ƙarƙashin gyara AGPL / Bitwarden License Agreement, kuma rahotonsu na bayyana gaskiya jama'a ne.

Babu ɗayan kamfanin da ke da rikodin haɗin kai tare da buƙatun sa ido marasa garanti, har zuwa abin da ake iya tabbatarwa a fili. Idan ikon shari'a na Switzerland yana da mahimmanci ga tsarin barazanar ku, Proton Pass yana da gefe. Idan kuna son guje wa ikon shari'a gaba ɗaya, zaɓin hosting na kai na Bitwarden kawai ya yi hakan.

Amfani na ƙungiya da ƙungiya

Ga mutane guda ɗaya, tsare-tsaren mutum ɗaya na dukansu sun rufe komai. Ga ƙungiyoyi da ƙungiyoyi, kasuwancin ya fi rikitarwa.

Bitwarden yana da samfurin ƙungiya mai girma. Yana ba da SAML/SSO, SCIM user provisioning, directory sync (tare da Azure AD, Google Workspace, Okta, OneLogin, JumpCloud), da manufofin masana'anta (buƙatun ƙarfin kalmar shiga, tilasta 2FA). Tsarin ƙungiyoyi $3/mai amfani/wata ne, Masana'anta $6/mai amfani/wata.

Proton Pass don Kasuwanci yana rufe abubuwan asali: vaults na ƙungiya, sarrafa masu amfani, rahoton gudanarwa. Ya fi sabuwa (aka ƙaddamar 2024) kuma har yanzu yana kama akan SSO da directory sync. An haɗa a cikin tsare-tsaren Proton Business ($9.99/mai amfani/wata) wanda kuma ya haɗa da Mail/VPN/Drive kasuwanci.

Idan kamfanin ku ya yi amfani da Google Workspace ko Microsoft 365 kuma kuna kula da SSO a yau, Bitwarden shine zaɓin mafi ƙanƙanta. Idan kamfanin ku ya kasance cikin dukan sabisan Proton, Proton Pass don Kasuwanci shine zaɓin haɗe.

Al'amuran gefe na ainihi

Wasu takamaiman abubuwa da ba su dace da kyau a cikin matrix fasalin:

Farfadowa lokacin da kuka manta kalmar sirrin ku. Bitwarden ba shi da farfadowa — idan ka manta da kalmar sirri, vault ba za a iya farfado da shi ta hanyar ƙira ba. Proton Pass haka ne, amma idan kuna amfani da asusun Proton, asusun Proton ɗin ku yana da farfadowa daban (waya, email, mabuɗin farfadowa). Wannan ba ya mayar muku da kalmar sirrin Pass da kuka manta — yana mayar da ku cikin asusun Proton don ku iya fara sabuwar vault Pass. Bayan sun kasance cikakkun hanyar "sake saita kalmar shiga" a ma'anar al'ada.

Jigilar bayanai waje. Dukansu suna goyan bayan fitar da CSV mai tsabta. Bitwarden kuma yana goyan bayan fitar da JSON tare da cikakken vault fidelity (babban fayiloli, abubuwan da aka makala, bayanin kula). Proton Pass yana fitar da CSV da kuma tsarin backup rufaffen. Ba ɗayansu da ya kulle ku a ciki.

Samun offline. Bitwarden yana da ainihin yanayin offline — bayan sync, za ku iya buɗe da karanta vault ɗin ku ba tare da hanyar sadarwa ba. Proton Pass yana da offline-read amma yana buƙatar hanyar sadarwa don kowane aikin rubutu, tunda canje-canje dole ne su bi ta servers na Proton.

Auto-fill na katin credit / identity. Dukansu suna goyan bayansa. Aiwatar da Bitwarden ya ɗan fi granular (abubuwa daban don identity vs. kati, adireshi da yawa a kowane identity). Proton Pass yana ɗaukar komai kamar "abubuwa tare da filayen da aka rubuta".

Sarrafa TOTP. Dukansu na iya ajiye sirrin TOTP a cikin-vault da auto-fill lambar mai lambobi 6. Wasu ƙwararrun tsaro suna ba da shawara a kan wannan a dalilan cewa idan vault ɗin ku ya lalace, abubuwa biyu suna faɗuwa gaba ɗaya — amma ga yawancin masu amfani, dacewa ya inganta karɓar 2FA sosai, wanda shine nasarar tsaro.

Shawarar mu

Ga mai amfani mai mayar da hankali kan sirri a 2026, ga tsarin yanke shawara mai tsabta:

  1. Ka riga ka yi amfani da Proton Mail, VPN, ko Drive akan tsarin biyan kuɗi → Proton Pass. An haɗa shi kyauta, alamun email suna haɗuwa sosai, kuma kuna samun labarin farfadowa mai haɗin kai.
  2. Kuna son mafi kyawun mai sarrafa kalmomin shiga kyauta, lokaci → Bitwarden. Abubuwa marasa iyaka kyauta, da kuma hosting na kai kyauta idan kuna so.
  3. Kuna gudanar da kayan aikin ku kuma kuna son sarrafawa → Bitwarden (self-hosted).
  4. Kuna son alamun email mafi yawa / burner-email privacy → Proton Pass.
  5. Kuna aiki a kamfani da ke buƙatar SSO / SCIM / directory sync yau → Bitwarden Enterprise.
  6. Kun kasance cikin dukan Proton kuma kuna son biyan kuɗi ɗaya → Proton Pass (ta hanyar Proton Unlimited).

Dukansu samfuran za su kiyaye kalmomin shigar ku cikin aminci fiye da duk abin da kuke yi yanzu idan ba ku yi amfani da mai sarrafa kalmomin shiga kwata-kwata ba. Mafi munin zaɓi shine rashin zaɓi.

Masu alaƙa

Yadda za a yi ƙaura daga Bitwarden zuwa Proton Pass

Ƙaura mai aminci na mintuna 5 da ke kiyaye lambar TOTP, tsarin babban fayil, da abubuwan da aka makala.

  1. Fitar da vault ɗin Bitwarden ku kamar CSV:A cikin vault na yanar gizo na Bitwarden, je zuwa Kayan aiki → Fitar da Vault → zaɓi tsarin `.csv` → shigar da kalmar sirrin ku → Fitarwa. Za ku sami fayil mai suna `bitwarden_export_YYYY-MM-DD.csv`. Ku ajiye wannan tab buɗe; kar ku rufe browser ba tukuna.
  2. Ƙirƙirar asusun Proton Pass ɗin ku (ko shiga):Ziyarci proton.me/pass kuma ku yi rajista don asusu kyauta ko Plus. Idan ka riga ka yi amfani da Proton Mail/VPN/Drive, shaidu iri ɗaya suna aiki. Ka saita kalmar sirri mai ƙarfi — wannan ita ce kawai mabuɗin da ke kare vault ɗinku, don haka ku yi ta da tsawo da ta musamman.
  3. Shigo da Bitwarden CSV:A cikin Proton Pass yanar gizo → Saitunan → Shigowa → Zaɓi Bitwarden → Upload fayil ɗin CSV → Duba abubuwan da aka gano → Tabbatar. Proton Pass zai buɗe CSV a cikin gida, ya sake ɓoye kowane abu tare da mabuɗin vault ɗin Proton Pass ku, kuma ya upload. Yawanci yana ɗaukar dakika 30-60 ga abubuwa 500-1000.
  4. Tabbatar da lambar TOTP har yanzu tana aiki:Buɗe 3-5 na asusun ku da aka ba da damar 2FA a Proton Pass kuma ku tabbatar da lambar mai lambobi 6 da aka nuna ya yi daidai da abin da gidajen yanar gizon ke tsammani. Sirrin TOTP ana adana su a cikin fitar da CSV amma a wasu lokuta alamar da bai dace ba ta haifar da shigowa cikin abu mara kyau — gwadawa kafin dogaro.
  5. Duba tsarin babban fayil:Fitar da Bitwarden ya haɗa da "babban fayil" metadata; Proton Pass ya zana waɗannan zuwa "vaults". Duba tsarin vault ku kuma ku sake suna duk abin da bai dace ba. Zaku iya ja-da-sauke abubuwa tsakanin vaults bayan-shigowa.
  6. Share fitar da CSV cikin aminci:Wannan mai mahimmanci ne — CSV yana ƙunshe da kowane kalmar shiga a cikin rubutu mara kyau. A macOS/Linux gudanar da `shred -u bitwarden_export_*.csv`; a Windows, yi amfani da SDelete daga Sysinternals ko Eraser. Wawushe ɗin Recycle Bin bai isa ba.
  7. Fita daga Bitwarden akan tsofaffin na'urori:Bitwarden → Saitunan → Fita, a kan kowane na'ura da kuka shiga. Wannan ya soke tsofaffin alamun zama. Ku ajiye asusun Bitwarden ɗin ku a raye kwana 30 idan kun gano abubuwan da ba su nan ba bayan ƙaura — sannan ku share shi lokacin da kuka tabbata.
  8. Gwada shiga na ainihi akan mobile da desktop:Shigar da Proton Pass akan wayarku (App Store / Play Store) da desktop (browser extension don Chrome/Firefox/Safari/Edge), shiga, kuma a zahiri shiga cikin shafuka 3-5 ta amfani da auto-fill. Kama matsalolin UX a rana 1 ya fi gano su a lokacin shiga mai mahimmanci.

Tambayoyin Da Ake Yawan Yi

Labarai masu alaƙa

Proton Pass

Imel Mai Ɓoyewa

Menene 2FA?

Lissafin Sirri

Proton VPN