Gajeriyar amsa
Idan kuna tambayar "shin in matsa daga Google Drive zuwa Proton Drive?", tambayar da ke bayan tambayar yawanci ta rabu zuwa shari'o'i biyu:
Shari'a A — Kuna kula da sirri musamman. I, ku canza. Proton Drive yana ɓoye fayilolinku a na'urarka kafin ɗorawa; Google Drive ba haka ba. Wannan ba bambancin fasali ba ne — bambanci ne na tushen gine-gine. Babu abin da Google ke yi da 2FA ko "sarrafa kamfani" da ya rufe gibin. Idan sirri ya damu, kuna amfani da samfur inda mai samarwa ba zai iya karanta fayilolinku ba a zahiri, ba wanda suka yi alkawarin ba sa yi ba.
Shari'a B — Kuna kula da fasaloli + haɗin gwiwa. Google Drive har yanzu ya yi nasara akan wannan gefe. Google Docs tare da gyare-gyaren haɗin gwiwa na lokaci guda yana da gaske mafi kyau, apps na wayar hannu na Google sun fi kyakkyawa, kuma tsarin na ɓangare na uku (haɗin Zapier, apps na CAD, kayan aikin zane) yana da girma. Proton Docs yana da kyau don 2024 amma yana bayan shekaru 2-3.
Mafi yawan mutane suna gauraye. Don wannan shari'a ta tsakiya: ku canza don fayilolin da ke da mahimmancin sirri (takaddun haraji, bayanan magani, ID, kayan jarida na tushe, hotuna masu sirri) kuma ku ci gaba da amfani da Google don ayyukan takardun haɗin gwiwa da kuke rabawa da wasu waɗanda ba sa amfani da Proton. Amfani da su biyu yana da kyau — wannan ba yanke shawara na duka-ko-babu komai ba ne.
Sauran wannan labarin shine kwatancen gaskiya, dalla-dalla don haka za ku iya daidaita wanne yanayi ya dace da yanayin ku.
Tsaro da rufewa — ainihin bambanci
Ayyukan biyun suna ɓoye bayanai a hutawa a kan saboninsu da kuma a cikin jigilar kaya ta HTTPS. Inda suka bambanta shine wa ke riƙe da mabuɗan buɗewa.
Proton Drive
Ana ɓoye fayilolinku a na'urarka da mabuɗin da aka samo daga kalmar sirrin asusunku. Rubutun da aka ɓoye shi ne abin da ke tafiya zuwa sabonin Proton. Proton ba ta taɓa samun mabuɗan buɗewa ba. Idan aka yi wa sabonin Proton hari, mai kai hari ya sami rubutun sirri. Idan an ba Proton takardun kotu, za su iya ba da rubutun sirri amma ba za su iya buɗe shi ba. Idan ma'aikacin Proton ya zama dan damfara, suna ganin rubutun sirri.
Wannan shine rufewa na "babu-shiga" ko "babu-sani". Yana daidai da gine-ginen da aka saita yadda ya kamata na gudanar da kalmomin sirri (Bitwarden, Proton Pass), kamar Signal, kamar iCloud's Advanced Data Protection.
Bayanan fasaha: rufewa na AES-256 da aka tabbatar, mabuɗai da aka samo ta KDF mai ƙarfi (Argon2id), mabuɗai masu asymmetric don rabawa. Proton ta buga takardar tsarin cryptographic a proton.me/blog/drive-security-model. An yi binciken waje (Securitum, 2023).
Musayar: idan kun manta da kalmar sirrin ku kuma kun rasa jumlar maidowar ku, fayilolinku sun ɓace. Babu wanda a Proton da zai iya taimakon ku. Wannan ba kurakure ba ne — shi ne kayan da ke sa rufewa na babu-shiga ya zama babu-shiga da gaske.
Google Drive
Google Drive yana ɓoye fayiloli a hutawa a kan sabonin Google. Google kuma tana riƙe da mabuɗan buɗewa. Wannan yana nufin:
- Bututun ML na Google suna karanta fayilolinku. Gano damfarewa na Gmail, fasalin "nemo takaddun da ke da alaƙa" na Drive, binciken tushen abun ciki na Google Photos — waɗannan duk suna buƙatar tsarin Google ya karanta abubuwan ku.
- Robots na manufofin Google suna bincika fayilolinku. Gano CSAM na atomatik, gano tashin hankali, da bututun tilasta TOS suna duba abin da kuke ɗorawa. Akwai kuskure na karya — babban shari'ar San Francisco na 2022 (uba da aka nuna don hotunan da ya aika ga likitan yara) ta zama labarin ƙasa.
- Takardun kotu suna dawo da rubutu a fili. Google tana karɓar dubaru da dubban buƙatun bayanan gwamnati a kowace shekara kuma tana bin yawancinsu. Suna buga rahoton haske. Abin da suke ba da shi abubuwan da ke cikin fayil da aka buɗe.
- Admin na Workspace na iya ganin komai. Idan Google Drive ɗinku wani bangare ne na asusun Workspace (aiki/makaranta), admin yana da damar bincike ga duk abin da kuka taɓa adanawa.
Google ba ta musanta wani daga cikin wannan ba. Takardarsu ta fili ta lura cewa "Google na iya samun damar shiga abun ciki na mai amfani don takamaiman dalilai ciki har da hidimar samfur, samar da tsaro da rigakafin cin zarafi, da bin tsarin shari'a."
Hukunci akan rufewa: Proton Drive ya fi sirri a tsari. Google Drive ya fi samun dama a tsari (ga Google, ga robots na Google, ga hakkokin shari'a na Google). Wannan ba gibin fasali ba ne — gibin zane ne. Ba ya rufewa da 2FA ko matakai na biyan kuɗi.
Farashi
Kwatanta tuffa-da-tuffa a matakin 200 GB inda mafi yawan masu amfani ke saukowa.
| Shiri | Proton Drive | Google One |
|---|---|---|
| Kyauta | 2 GB | 15 GB (an raba tare da Gmail + Photos) |
| 100 GB | — | $1.99/wata |
| 200 GB | $3.99/wata | $2.99/wata |
| 500 GB | An haɗa tare da Proton Unlimited ($12.99/wata, bundles Mail + VPN + Pass + Calendar) | — |
| 2 TB | An haɗa tare da Proton Unlimited idan ku kaɗai kuke amfani da shi (1 TB kowannenku har zuwa iyali 6) | $9.99/wata |
| Rabon iyali | I (masu amfani 6 akan Proton Family) | I (masu amfani 6 akan Google One) |
| Rangwame na shekara | ~17% vs wata-wata | ~17% vs wata-wata |
Abubuwan da za a ɗauka:
- Kai tsaye 200 GB Drive-kawai: Google ya fi arha da $1/wata ($2.99 vs $3.99). Bambancin $12/shekara. Ba mai tuƙin yanke shawara ba.
- Proton Unlimited shine wasan kimantawa. A $12.99/wata kuna samun 500 GB na ajiya da aka ɓoye + Proton Mail + Proton VPN + Proton Pass + Proton Calendar. Idan kun riga kun shirya biyan kusan $5-10/wata don VPN, mai sarrafa kalmomin sirri, ko imel da aka ɓoye, Unlimited yana biyan kansa da sauri.
- Matakan kyauta sun bambanta cikin amfani. 15 GB kyauta na Google an raba su a cikin Drive + Gmail + Photos, wanda ke cike da sauri idan kuna amfani da Gmail sosai. 2 GB kyauta na Proton ƙarami ne amma ya isa don gwada kwarewar.
Fasaloli gaba da gaba
| Fasali | Proton Drive | Google Drive |
|---|---|---|
| Rufewa daga ƙarshe zuwa ƙarshe | ✅ Tsohuwa, ko da yaushe a kunne | ❌ A'a |
| Abokan ciniki masu buɗe tushe | ✅ (tebur, wayar hannu, yanar gizo) | ❌ A rufe |
| Ɗorawa / saukewa na fayil | ✅ Girman fayil marar iyaka zuwa hulewar shiri | ✅ Mafi girma 5 TB kowace fayil |
| Sync na babban fayil (tebur) | ✅ Windows, macOS, Linux | ✅ Windows, macOS, ChromeOS |
| Damar wayar hannu ba tare da hanyar sadarwa ba | ✅ Alamta fayiloli don ba tare da hanyar sadarwa ba | ✅ Ya fi karɓuwa |
| Gyare-gyaren haɗin gwiwa | ⚠️ Docs + Sheets, shekaru 2-3 a baya | ✅ Mafi kyau a aji |
| Sharhi akan fayiloli | ✅ (an ɓoye) | ✅ |
| Tarihin sigar | ✅ Sigogin 10+ da aka riƙe | ✅ Kwanaki 30+ da aka riƙe |
| Mahaɗan raba fayil | ✅ An ɓoye daga ƙarshe zuwa ƙarshe zuwa masu karɓar Proton, mahaɗan da aka kare da kalmar sirri don waɗanda ba Proton ba | ✅ Izinin da aka ƙayyade |
| Ƙarewar mahaɗi | ✅ | ✅ |
| Rabawa da aka kare da kalmar sirri | ✅ | ✅ (an biya) |
| Haɗin ɓangare na uku | ⚠️ Iyakacce | ✅ Dubaru (Zapier, Figma, Slack, Notion, da sauransu) |
| Admin na ƙungiya/Workspace | ✅ (Proton Business) | ✅ (Google Workspace) |
| Yanki | 🇨🇭 Switzerland | 🇺🇸 United States |
| Lambar sabar buɗe tushe | ❌ | ❌ |
| App na musamman na hotuna | ❌ (Proton Drive kawai ya adana su) | ✅ Google Photos tare da binciken AI, abubuwan tunawa, da sauransu |
Inda Google ya yi nasara da gaske
Google Docs ya kyakkyawa ta hanyar da Proton Docs bai kai ba tukuna. Haɗin gwiwa na lokaci guda akan takarda mai shafi 50 tare da mutane 5 suna gyarawa yana aiki ba matsala akan Google; akan Proton Docs, yana aiki amma tare da jinkirin sync lokaci-lokaci da ƙarancin fasali. Nau'ikan ginshiƙi, teburan pivot, macros, ƙari — duk sun fi ci gaba akan Google.
Google Photos samfur ne daban amma yana raba ajiya da Drive. Binciken fuska / abu / wurin da AI ke jagoranta yana da amfani da gaske kuma ba shi da kwatankwacin a Proton Drive (Proton Drive yana adana hotuna amma baya bincika su — da nufin, da yake ba za su iya ganin abubuwan da aka buɗe ba).
Tsarin ɓangare na uku — Google Drive yana haɗe da kowane kayan aikin SaaS. Zapier, IFTTT, Notion, Airtable, mafi yawan shirye-shiryen CAD, kayan aikin zane, kayan aikin lissafi, CRMs — duk suna magana da Google Drive. Proton Drive ba shi da wannan tsari.
Kyawawan app na wayar hannu — Apps na Google sun sami dubawa na shekaru 15+. Na Proton sun sami shekaru 2-4. Gibin yana nunawa a cikin ƙananan abubuwa kamar saurin bincike, samar da hotuna ƙanana, da fitar da cache ba tare da hanyar sadarwa ba.
Inda Proton ya yi nasara da gaske
Sirri, kamar yadda aka bayyana a sama. Wannan shine babban dalili guda ɗaya don canzawa.
Jerin abubuwan da aka haɗa — idan kun riga kun shirya biyan VPN + mai sarrafa kalmomin sirri + imel mai sirri, Proton Unlimited ya rufe duk huɗu a farashi guda.
Yanki — Dokar Federal ta Switzerland akan Kariyar Bayanai tana cikin mafi ƙarfin dokokin sirri na duniya. Dokar Amurka (Dokar CLOUD, Dokar Sadarwar da aka Adana) ba ta da ƙarfi.
Babu ayyukan asusu na tushen abun ciki — ba za a dakatar da asusunku ba saboda robon ML ya yi kuskure da hoton magani da wani abu dabam. Proton ba ta iya ganin abin da kuke ɗorawa.
Abokan ciniki masu buɗe tushe — apps na tebur da wayar hannu duk masu buɗe tushe ne. Kuna iya tabbatar da rufewa yana faruwa da gaske.
Haɗin Proton Mail — mahaɗan Proton Drive suna aika ta Proton Mail suna da ƙarin Layer na rufewa daga ƙarshe zuwa ƙarshe tsakanin masu amfani da Proton.
Rabawa da haɗin gwiwa
Duka samfuran suna barin ku ku raba fayiloli tare da:
- Takamaiman masu amfani (asusu zuwa asusu)
- Mahaɗan jama'a (duk wanda ke da URL)
- Mahaɗan da aka kare da kalmar sirri
Rabawa na Proton Drive tsakanin masu amfani na Proton biyu an ɓoye su daga ƙarshe zuwa ƙarshe a duka ƙarshen — fayil da aka raba an sake ɓoye shi da mabuɗin jama'a na mai karɓa. Idan mai karɓa ba ya kan Proton, suna samun mahaɗi zuwa kallon buɗewa na tushen browser (mabuɗin yana cikin guntun URL, don haka sabonin Proton ba za su iya karantawa ba amma kowane abokin gaba da ke da mahaɗin zai iya).
Rabawa na Google Drive suna ba masu karɓa kallo kai tsaye akan sabonin Google. Babu bambancin rufewa tsakanin mai rabawa da mai karɓa — Google tana ganin komai ta kowace hanya.
Don aikin haɗin gwiwa inda kuke buƙatar gyare-gyare na lokaci guda tare da mutane 5+ akan takarda, Google Drive har yanzu shine kwarewar da ta fi santsi. Proton Docs yana kamawa amma bai rufe gibin ba tukuna.
Apps na wayar hannu da tebur
iOS
- Proton Drive: App mai cikakken fasali, buɗewar biometric, alamta-don-ba tare da hanyar sadarwa ba, bincike, ɗorawa daga Photos. Mai iya jurewa amma ba ya gasa da kyawawan Google.
- Google Drive: UI mai kyakkyawa, hotuna ƙanana masu sauri, haɗin Google Photos + Gmail mai tsayi. Mai mulki don dalili.
Android
- Proton Drive: Fasali-kwatankwacin sigar iOS. Yana haɗuwa da takaddun raba na Android.
- Google Drive: An shigar da shi a kan mafi yawan na'urorin Android; haɗin da ya fi zurfi.
Tebur (Windows / macOS / Linux)
- Proton Drive: Abokan cikin sync na tebur tun 2024. Goyan bayan Linux ya fi na Google — Google bai taɓa fitar da abokin ciniki na Linux Drive a hukumance ba (akwai "Drive File Stream" da ya dace + shirye-shiryen rclone marasa hukuma).
- Google Drive: App na tebur akan Windows / macOS, babu wani abu a hukumance akan Linux.
Yanar gizo
- Dukansu sun kyakkyawa.
Sirri da yanki
Proton Drive Proton AG ta yi aiki da shi a Switzerland. Dokar Swiss:
- Tana buƙatar odar kotu don kowane buƙatar bayanai
- Ba za ta iya tilasta Proton ta karye rufewa da Proton ba ta riƙe mabuɗai ba
- Tana waje da ƙungiyar raba bayanai na idanu 14
- Tana buga rahoton haske da ke nuna buƙatun gwamnati da ayyukan amsa
Google Drive Google LLC ta yi aiki da shi a Amurka. Dokar Amurka:
- Dokar CLOUD tana barin hukumomin Amurka su nemi bayanai daga kamfanonin Amurka a duniya ba tare da izinin yankunan waje ba
- Takardun Tsaron Ƙasa suna ba da damar buƙatun bayanai ba tare da kulawar shari'a ba a wasu lokuta
- Ka'idar "ɓangare na uku" a tarihi tana nufin bayanai da kuka ba Google da son rai suna da kariyar Fourth Amendment mai rauni (yana ci gaba ta Carpenter, amma har yanzu ya fi rauni da kai-tsaye-ga-mai amfani)
- Google tana buga rahoton haske, wanda ya cika; adadin amsa ga buƙatun gwamnatin Amurka kusan 80% ne.
Idan ƙirar barazanar ku ta haɗa da "gwamnatin da ba na amince da ita gaba ɗaya tana son fayilolina", Switzerland > Amurka.
Idan ƙirar barazanar ku ita ce "hackers na iya karya Google", tsaron gefen sabar Google yana da gaske a matakin farko kuma kuna da kyau ta kowace hanya. Amma hackers-karya-Google ba shi ne babban haɗari ba; abin da Google (da masu amfani da su) ke yi da fayilolinku kullum shine abin da ke haifar da bambancin tsari.
Shawarar mu ta amfani da yanayi
1. Kuna aiki da takaddun ku kaɗai kuma ba ku yawan haɗin gwiwa ba. Ku canza zuwa Proton Drive gaba ɗaya. Ba za ku lura da gibin fasali ba don aikin solo, kuma haɓakar sirri tana gaske.
2. Kuna cikakke akan Google Workspace don aiki kuma ba za ku iya motsawa ba tare da motsar da duka ƙungiyar ba. Ku ci gaba da amfani da Google Drive don takaddun aiki. Don fayilolin sirri (dawo da haraji, bayanan magani, ID, hotunan iyali da kuke kula da su), ku kafa asusun Proton Drive na kyauta ko Plus ku motsa waɗannan musamman. Hybrid yana aiki.
3. Kuna biyan VPN da mai sarrafa kalmomin sirri daban. Proton Unlimited a $12.99/mo shine wasan kimantawa — kuna samun Drive, Mail, VPN, Pass, Calendar, kuma a zahiri ya fi arha da biyan $8 + $3 + $5 don ayyuka uku daban.
4. Kuna kan tsarin Apple tare da iCloud. Kunna iCloud Advanced Data Protection idan ba ku yi ba — wannan yana kawo tsaron iCloud Drive zuwa matakin Proton, kuma haɗin tare da komai Apple ya riga ya tsayi. Proton Drive ya zama da yawa sai dai idan kuna son 'yancin kai daga Apple.
5. Mai daukar hoto / mahallin bidiyo tare da 1 TB+ na kafofin watsa labarai. Proton Unlimited yana ba ku 500 GB; don 1-2 TB kuna duban haɓaka zuwa Proton Family. Google One a $9.99/wata don 2 TB har yanzu ya fi arha a wannan mataki. Idan sirrin hoto/bidiyo bai damu ba fiye da farashi, Google ya yi nasara. Idan ya yi, ku biya Proton.
6. Kun kasance ɗan jarida, mai fafutuka, ko kowa da ke sarrafa abubuwa masu mahimmanci. Ba kawai "ya kamata ku canja ba — ya kamata ku yi la'akari da wannan wajibi. Kayan tushen tushe, takaddun shari'a, da bincike mai mahimmanci bai kamata su zauna a kan kowane mai samarwa da zai iya karantu ba. Proton Drive tare da kalmar sirri mai ƙarfi, da kuma madadin gida zuwa rumbun waje da aka ɓoye, shine mafi ƙarancin.
Matsalolin ƙaura da ya kamata a sani
Fayilolin da aka raba da ku ba su fito da kyau ba. Google Takeout kawai ya haɗa da fayilolin da kuke mallaka. Fayilolin da wasu suka raba da ku suna buƙatar a sauke su ɗaya bayan ɗaya ko a sake raba su daga mai shi. Wannan shine babban matsalar lokacin ƙaura.
Tsarin Google Photos baya rayuwa. Idan asusun Google ɗinku yana da Photos tare da albums na al'ada, alamun fuska, da tunanin AI, waɗannan duk metadata na samfur-Photos ne — ba ainihin abun ciki na fayil ba. Lokacin da kuka motsa fayiloli zuwa Proton Drive, kuna rasa Layer na tsari. Ku yi shiri don dabarun tsarin hoto daban (kundin Lightroom na gida, sabis na daukar hoto daban kamar Ente ko Immich mai-gudanar da kai).
Canje-canjen fayilolin ofis. Idan kuna da Google Docs (tsarin asali), ba fayiloli ba ne da za a iya jigilar su — tsarin Google ne na musamman wanda kawai ke aiki a cikin Google Docs. Takeout yana fitar da su azaman .docx / .xlsx ta tsohuwa, wanda Proton Docs zai iya buɗewa amma na iya rasa tsarin. Ku bincika kowane takarda da aka canza kafin ku share ainihin Google.
Rabawa drives a cikin Workspace. Idan kuna a cikin ƙungiyar Workspace, "Shared Drives" (fayilolin da ƙungiyar ke mallaka, ba ku ba) ba su fita ta Takeout na sirri ba. Za ku buƙaci shigar da admin na ƙungiya.
Wani abu ɗaya — Proton Drive ba shine kaɗai zaɓin ba
Wannan labarin ya mayar da hankali kan Proton Drive saboda shi ne mafi shaharar zaɓin rufewa daga ƙarshe zuwa ƙarshe na masu amfani. Ya kamata a san madadin idan Proton bai dace ba:
- Tresorit — Swiss, rufewa na E2E, mai mayar da hankali kan kamfani. Ya fi tsada da Proton, fasalolin admin na ƙungiya da yawa.
- Sync.com — Kanada, rufewa na E2E, farashi mai gasa, ƙarancin sanin alama.
- pCloud tare da ƙarin Crypto — Swiss, rufewa na E2E yana biya ƙari a kan tsarin biyan kuɗi na yau da kullum. Zai iya zama mai fa'ida don sayayya na rayuwa guda.
- iCloud Drive tare da Advanced Data Protection — Tsarin Apple, E2E don Drive, Photos, Notes, Backup.
- Mai-gudanar da kai — Nextcloud, Seafile, ko OwnCloud akan VPS ko NAS na gida. Mafi girman sirri, mafi girman nauyin kulawa.
Duba kwatancen ajiyar fayil da aka ɓoye don zurfin kwatanta Proton Drive da Tresorit da Sync.com.
Masu alaƙa
- Bitar Proton Drive — zurfi mai tsayawa
- Kwatancen ajiyar fayil da aka ɓoye — kallon mai-samarwa da yawa mai faɗi
- Imel da aka ɓoye — Proton Mail, Tutanota, Mailbox.org
- Lissafin Binciken Sirri — binciken matakai 20 don asusunku
- Kwatancen sirri na OS na tebur — OS da ajiyar gajimare ku ke gudana da shi ma yana da mahimmanci