Impendulo emfushane
Uma ubuza "ngabe kufanele ngisuke ku-Google Drive ngiye ku-Proton Drive?", umbuzo ongemuva kombuzo uvame ukwehluka abe izimo ezimbili:
Icala A — Uyakhathalela ubumfihlo ngokuqondile. Yebo, guquka. Proton Drive ibethela amafayela akho kuthiwansi yakho ngaphambi kokulayisha; Google Drive ayikwenzi. Lokho akuyona umehluko wezici — kumehluko wesakhiwo esiyisisekelo. Akukho lutho Google elukwenzayo nge-2FA noma "ukulawula kwezimboni" okuvala igebe. Uma ubumfihlo bubalulekile, usebenzisa umkhiqizo lapho umhlinzeki angakwazi ngokomzimba ukufunda amafayela akho, hhayi lowo athembisa ukuthi akakwenzi.
Icala B — Uyakhathalela izici + ukusebenzisana. Google Drive isawina kuleyondima. Google Docs ngokuhlela okusebenzisanayo kwesikhathi sangempela lungcono kakhulu ekilasini, izinhlelo zikaMobile ze-Google zihlelwe kakhulu, futhi i-ecosystem yomuntu wesithathu (ukuxhumana kwe-Zapier, izinhlelo ze-CAD, amathuluzi okuklama) inkulu. Proton Docs ilungile ngo-2024 kodwa ineminyaka eyi-2-3 ngemuva.
Abantu abaningi bangumxube. Kulelo cala phakathi: guqukela amafayela abalulekile ngokwemfihlo (amadokhumenti ezintela, amarekhodi ezokwelapha, ama-ID, izinto zocwaningo lwabezindaba, izithombe ezisondelelene) futhi gcina Google ngamadokhumenti omsebenzi wokusebenzisana owabelana nabanye abangasebenzisi Proton. Ukusebenzisa kokubili kulungile — lokhu akuyona isinqumo sonke-noma-akukho.
Okusele kwalesi sihloko ukuqhathanisa okunengqondo, okuningiliziwe ukuze ukwazi ukulinganisa ukuthi imuphi umodi olingana nesimo sakho.
Ukuphepha nokubethela — umehluko wangempela
Womabili amasevisi abethela idatha ekuphumeni kumaseva awo nakulokho okuhamba nge-HTTPS. Lapho ehluka khona obani abanambobo bokuvula.
Proton Drive
Amafayela akho abethelwa kuthiwansi yakho ngambobo athathwe kwiphasiwedi yekhonti lakho. Ama-blob abethelwe yilokho okuhamba kumaseva ka-Proton. Proton ayinabo ambobo okuvula. Uma amaseva ka-Proton ehlaselwe, umhlaseli uthola i-ciphertext. Uma Proton ibekwa umthetho ukuthi inikeze idatha, banganikezisa i-ciphertext kodwa abangayivula. Uma isebenzi le-Proton liphambuka, libona i-ciphertext.
Lokhu kuyibhoboza "elibhena-ukufinyelela" noma "elingalwazi-lutho". Kuyisakhiwo esifanayo njengelawula wephasiwedi elilungiselelwe kahle (Bitwarden, Proton Pass), njengo-Signal, njenge-iCloud's Advanced Data Protection.
Imininingwane eyingcweti: AES-256 authenticated encryption, ombobo abathathwe nge-KDF eqinile (Argon2id), ombobo be-asymmetric wokwabelana. Proton ishicilela idokhumenti yokwakhiwa kwe-cryptographic ku-proton.me/blog/drive-security-model. Iye yahlolwa ngaphandle (Securitum, 2023).
Ukuthengiselana: uma ukhohlwa iphasiwedi yakho futhi ulahlekelwe umusho wokubuyisa, amafayela akho asehambile. Akekho ku-Proton ongakusiza. Lokho akuyona iphutha — kuyisici esenza ukubethela okunga-access ukuba ukungafinyeleli ngempela.
Google Drive
Google Drive ibethela amafayela ekuphumeni kumaseva ka-Google. Google ibambe futhi ambobo okuvula. Lokhu kusho:
- Imijikelezo ye-ML ka-Google ifunda amafayela akho. Ukubhonwa kwe-phishing kwe-Gmail, isici se-Drive "sithola amadokhumenti ahlobene", usesho olusekelwe kokuqukethwe kwe-Google Photos — konke lokhu kudinga ukuthi izinqubo zika-Google zifunde okuqukethwe kwakho.
- Ama-bot enqubomgomo ka-Google ahlola amafayela akho. Ukubhonwa kwe-CSAM okuzenzakalela, ukubhonwa kodlame, nemijikelezo yokuqinisekisa i-TOS ihlola lokho okulayishayo. Kukhona ukucasuka okuyimpazamo — icala eliphezulu elikhongolose lase-San Francisco elika-2022 (ubaba owabekwa uphawu ngesithombe asithathele ingane yakhe kodokotela) laba yizindaba zezwe lonke.
- Ama-subpoena abuyisela i-plaintext. Google ithola amakhulu ezinkulungwane zezicelo zedatha kahulumeni ngonyaka futhi ivumelana niningi lazo. Bashicilela umbiko wokubonakala. Abakuphayo yikuqukethwe kwamafayela akuvulelwe.
- Abaphathi be-Workspace bangabona konke. Uma Google Drive yakho iyingxenye yekhonti le-Workspace (umsebenzi/isikole), umphathi unokufinyelela okokubheka konke osuke wakugcina.
Google ayikuphiki okungaki. Iphepha labo elilodwa liyabonisa ukuthi "Google ingafinyelela kokuqukethwe komsebenzisi ngezinjongo ezithile kuhlanganisa ukusiza umkhiqizo, ukuhlinzeka ngokuphepha nokuvimbela ukusetshenziswa kabi, kanye nokuthobela inqubo yomthetho."
Ukujuluka kokubethela: Proton Drive iyimfihlo kakhulu ngokwesakhiwo. Google Drive iyafikeleleka kakhulu ngokwesakhiwo (ku-Google, kuma-bot ka-Google, ezimbopheni zomthetho zika-Google). Lokhu akuyona igebe lezici — ligebe lesakhiwo. Alivali nge-2FA noma ngamazinga akhokhelwayo.
Intengo
Qhathanisa ama-apula nama-apula esigabeni se-200 GB lapho abantu abaningi befinyelela khona.
| Icebo | Proton Drive | Google One |
|---|---|---|
| Mahhala | 2 GB | 15 GB (yabelanwe ne-Gmail + Photos) |
| 100 GB | — | $1.99/inyanga |
| 200 GB | $3.99/inyanga | $2.99/inyanga |
| 500 GB | Ifakiwe ne-Proton Unlimited ($12.99/inyanga, ibhidlela Mail + VPN + Pass + Calendar) | — |
| 2 TB | Ifakiwe ne-Proton Unlimited uma nguwe wedwa osebenzisayo (1 TB ngamunye kubasebenzisi abayi-6 bomndeni) | $9.99/inyanga |
| Ukwabelana komndeni | Yebo (abasebenzisi abayi-6 ku-Proton Family) | Yebo (abasebenzisi abayi-6 ku-Google One) |
| Isaphulelo sonyaka | ~17% vs inyanga | ~17% vs inyanga |
Imiphumela:
- Drive-kuphela okungoqo lwe-200 GB: Google ishibhile nge-$1/inyanga ($2.99 vs $3.99). Umehluko we-$12/unyaka. Akuyona isiqhubi sesinqumo.
- Proton Unlimited iyindlela yenani. Ku-$12.99/inyanga uthola i-500 GB yesitoreji esibethelwe + Proton Mail + Proton VPN + Proton Pass + Proton Calendar. Uma ubusuzokhokhela cishe u-$5-10/inyanga i-VPN, umlawuli wephasiwedi, noma i-email ebethelwe, Unlimited izikhokhelela masinyane.
- Amazinga amahhala ahluka ngokusebenziseka. I-15 GB yamahhala ka-Google yabelanwe phakathi kwe-Drive + Gmail + Photos, egcwala masinyane uma usebenzisa Gmail kakhulu. I-2 GB yamahhala ka-Proton incane kodwa kwanele ukuhlola ulwazi.
Izici ukuze zibhekane
| Isici | Proton Drive | Google Drive |
|---|---|---|
| Ukubethela kwe-end-to-end | ✅ Okuzenzakalela, kuhlale kuvuliwe | ❌ Cha |
| Amaklayinti avulekile | ✅ (desktop, mobile, web) | ❌ Uvalekile |
| Ukulayisha / ukudownload amafayela | ✅ Usayizi wefayela ongenasiphelo kuya kumyalo wechwama | ✅ Max 5 TB ngefayela |
| Ukuqondanisa kwefolda (desktop) | ✅ Windows, macOS, Linux | ✅ Windows, macOS, ChromeOS |
| Ukufinyelela kweselula ngaphandle kwe-intanethi | ✅ Maka amafayela ukuze afinyelele ngaphandle kwe-intanethi | ✅ Avumela kakhulu |
| Ukuhlela okusebenzisanayo | ⚠️ Docs + Sheets, iminyaka eyi-2-3 ngemuva | ✅ Okungcono kakhulu ekilasini |
| Amazwana kumafayela | ✅ (abethelwe) | ✅ |
| Umlando wezinguqulo | ✅ Izinguqulo eziyi-10+ zigciniwe | ✅ Izinsuku eziyi-30+ zigciniwe |
| Amalink okwabelana amafayela | ✅ Abethelwe kwe-end-to-end kubamukeli be-Proton, amalink avikelwe ngephasiwedi kubamukeli abangeyona Proton | ✅ Izivumelo ezinemininingwane |
| Ukuphelelwa kwelink | ✅ | ✅ |
| Izabelo ezivikelwe ngephasiwedi | ✅ | ✅ (akhokhelwayo) |
| Ukuxhumana kwangaphandle | ⚠️ Kulinganiselwe | ✅ Izinkulungwane (Zapier, Figma, Slack, Notion, njll) |
| Umphathi weqembu/Workspace | ✅ (Proton Business) | ✅ (Google Workspace) |
| Ubunikazi | 🇨🇭 Switzerland | 🇺🇸 United States |
| Ikhodi yeseva evulekile | ❌ | ❌ |
| I-app ekhethekile yezithombe | ❌ (Proton Drive iyazigcina nje) | ✅ Google Photos nge-AI search, izinkumbulo, njll |
Lapho Google ewina ngempela khona
Google Docs ihlelwe ngendlela Proton Docs engakayifanisi. Ukusebenzisana kwesikhathi sangempela edokumenthini enamakhasi angama-50 nabantu abayi-5 behlela kusebenza ngaphandle komthunzi ku-Google; ku-Proton Docs, kusebenza kodwa nge-sync lag yesikhatshana nezici ezingajulile. Izinhlobo zamashadi, amathebula e-pivot, ama-macro, ama-add-on — konke kuthuthuke ku-Google.
Google Photos umkhiqizo ohlukile kodwa wabelana isitoreji ne-Drive. Usesho olusekelwe kwe-AI lwezibuso / izinto / isiqephu luyasebenza futhi alunalokho okulingana ku-Proton Drive (Proton Drive igcina izithombe kodwa azikali — ngamabomu, ngoba azikwazi ukubona okuqukethwe okuvulelwe).
Uhlelo olungaphandle — Google Drive ihlanganiswe nawo wonke amathuluzi e-SaaS. Zapier, IFTTT, Notion, Airtable, izinhlelo eziningi ze-CAD, amathuluzi okuklama, ezezimali, ama-CRM — konke kukhuluma Google Drive. Proton Drive ayinalo lolu hlelo.
Ukucaca kwe-app yeselula — izinhlelo zika-Google zingeminyaka engu-15+ yokuphindelelwa. Ezika-Proton zineminyaka eyi-2-4. Igebe libonakala ezintweni ezincane njengesijubane sosesho, ukudalwa kwe-thumbnail, nokudonswa kwe-cache yangaphandle kwe-intanethi.
Lapho Proton ewina ngempela khona
Ubumfihlo, njengoba kushiwo ngenhla. Lesi yisizathu esisodwa esikhulu sokutshintsha.
Suite ebhidliwe — uma ubusuzokhokhela i-VPN + umlawuli wephasiwedi + i-email yobumfihlo, Proton Unlimited imbandakanya yonke emine ngentengo eyodwa.
Ubunikazi — Umthetho waseSwiss Federal Act on Data Protection ungomunye wemithetho yamandla yobumfihlo emhlabeni. Umthetho wase-US (CLOUD Act, Stored Communications Act) ubuthakathaka.
Izinyathelo zekhonti ezisekelwe kokukakana — ikhonti lakho alikwazi ukumiswa ngoba i-ML bot yenza iphutha lesithombe sokwelapha ngento enye. Proton ayikwazi ukubona lokho olayishayo.
Amaklayinti avulekile — izinhlelo ze-desktop nezelula zonke zivulekile. Ungaqinisekisa ukuthi ukubethela kwenzeka ngempela.
Ukuxhumana kwe-Proton Mail — amalink e-Proton Drive athunyelwa nge-Proton Mail anendawo engeziwe yokubethela kwe-end-to-end phakathi kwabasebenzisi be-Proton.
Ukwabelana nokusebenzisana
Womabili umkhiqizo akuvumela ukwabelana amafayela:
- Abasebenzisi abathile (ikhonti-kuya-ekhonti)
- Amalink omphakathi (noma ubani one-URL)
- Amalink avikelwe ngephasiwedi
Izabelo ze-Proton Drive phakathi kwabasebenzisi be-Proton ababili zibethelwe kwe-end-to-end emiphethweni yomabili — ifayela elilabanwayo libethelwa kabusha ngokhiye womphakathi womamukeli. Uma umamukeli engekho ku-Proton, uthola ilink yokubuka esekelwe ku-browser (ukhiye ukube ku-URL fragment, ngakho amaseva ka-Proton awakwazi ukulifunda kodwa noma yiluphi usongo lwelink lungakwenza).
Izabelo ze-Google Drive zinikeza abamukeli ukubuka okuqondile kumaseva ka-Google. Awukho umehluko wokubethela phakathi komabelani nomamukeli — Google ibona konke ngayodwa indlela.
Emsebenzini wokusebenzisana lapho udinga ukuhlela kwesikhathi sangempela nabantu abayi-5+ edokumenthini, Google Drive isayiyona into elula. Proton Docs iyafinyelela kodwa ayikavali igebe okwamanje.
Izinhlelo zeselula ne-desktop
iOS
- Proton Drive: I-app egcwele izici, ukuvula kwe-biometric, maka-ukuze-kungabi se-intanethi, usesho, layisha ku-Photos. Kuyafezeka kodwa akukhuphisani nocwebezelelo luka-Google.
- Google Drive: I-UI ecwentshelwe kakhulu, ama-thumbnail asheshayo, ukuxhumana okuqinile kwe-Google Photos + Gmail. Inkampani esebenzileyo ngesizathu.
Android
- Proton Drive: Izici zifana nezinhlelo ze-iOS. Ixhumana ne-Android share sheet.
- Google Drive: Ifakiwe ngaphambili eminingi yamathiwansi e-Android; ukuxhumana okujulile okukhongolose.
Desktop (Windows / macOS / Linux)
- Proton Drive: Amaklayinti okuqondanisa e-desktop okokuhlanganela kusukela ngo-2024. Ukwesekwa kwe-Linux kungcono kuna-Google — Google ayikaze yathumela ikhanyinti le-Drive le-Linux ngokusemthethweni (kukhona "Drive File Stream" workarounds + unofficial rclone setups).
- Google Drive: I-app ye-desktop ku-Windows / macOS, akukho okumsemthethweni ku-Linux.
Web
- Womabili ahlelwe.
Ubumfihlo nobuholi
Proton Drive iphethwe yi-Proton AG e-Switzerland. Umthetho wase-Swiss:
- Udinga umyalo wenkundla kunoma yisiphi isicelo sedatha
- Awakwazi ukuphoqa Proton ukuthi yephule ukubethela okungakho mbobo ukuze kunikeze
- Ungemuva kwehlanganiso lokuphazamisana lwezobuntlola ezine-14 Eyes
- Ushicilela umbiko wokubonakala obonisa izicelo zikahulumeni nezinyathelo zokuphendula
Google Drive iphethwe yi-Google LLC e-United States. Umthetho wase-US:
- I-CLOUD Act ivumela iziphathimandla zase-US ukucela idatha ezinkampanini zase-US emhlabeni wonke ngaphandle kokuvuma kobuholi bezinye izwe
- I-National Security Letters ivumela izicelo zedatha ngaphandle kokuphatha kwezinkantolo kwezinye izimo
- I-"third-party doctrine" ngokwembali yayisho idatha oyinikezile Google yayinokulinda amandla ancane e-Fourth Amendment (iguquka nge-Carpenter, kodwa isancane kunokuya-kumsebenzisi ngokuqondile)
- Google ushicilela umbiko wokubonakala, onemininingwane; izinga lokuphendula ezicekelweni zikahulumeni wase-US cishe ngo-80%.
Uma imodeli yakho yesongo ihlanganisa "uhulumeni engingawuthembi ngokugcwele ufuna amafayela ami", Switzerland > US.
Uma imodeli yakho yesongo ithi "amaheqha angahle ephule Google", ukuphepha kweseva ka-Google kungcono ngempela futhi mhlawumbe uvukuzi ngayodwa indlela. Kodwa amaheqha-aphula-Google akusona ubungozi obuyinhloko; yilokho Google (nabafinisi babo) abakwenzayo ngamafayela akho ngokuvamile okudala umehluko wesakhiwo.
Isincomo sethu ngokwesimo sokusetshenziswa
1. Usebenza ngamadokhumenti ngobumfihlo futhi awusebenzi sana kakhulu. Guqukela ku-Proton Drive ngokuphelele. Uzozwa kancane igebe lezici emsebenzini wodwa, futhi ukuthuthukiswa kobumfihlo kwangempela.
2. Uzimisele ku-Google Workspace emsebenzini futhi awukwazi ukusuka ngaphandle kokususa iqembu lonke. Qhubeka usebenzisa Google Drive ngamadokhumenti omsebenzi. Kumafayela omuntu siqu (imibuyiso yezintela, amarekhodi ezokwelapha, ama-ID, izithombe zomndeni ozikhathalelayo), misa ikhonti le-Proton Drive yamahhala noma Plus bese uyisa lawo ngokuqondile. Inhlanganisela iyasebenza.
3. Ukhokhela i-VPN nomulawuli wephasiwedi ngokwehlukana. Proton Unlimited ngu-$12.99/mo yindlela yenani — uthola Drive, Mail, VPN, Pass, Calendar, futhi ikushibhile kunokukhokha u-$8 + $3 + $5 izinsizakalo ezintathu ezihlukene.
4. Ukulula lwe-Apple ngoku-iCloud. Nika amandla i-iCloud Advanced Data Protection uma ungakayi — lokho kuletha ukuphepha kwe-iCloud Drive kuya ezingeni le-Proton, futhi ukuxhumana nawo wonke u-Apple kusuvele kuqinile. Proton Drive iba yinto engadingeki ngaphandle uma ufuna ukuzimela ku-Apple.
5. Umfoti / umdali wevidiyo ono-1 TB+ wemedia. Proton Unlimited ikutholela i-500 GB; ku-1-2 TB ubheka ukuthuthukisa ku-Proton Family. Google One ku-$9.99/inyanga ku-2 TB isashibhile kuleyosigaba. Uma ubumfihlo bezithombe/bevidiyo bubaluleke kancane kunezindleko, Google iyawina. Uma bubalulekile, bhadala Proton.
6. Uyintatheli, umklami, noma noma ubani ophatha izinto ezibucayi. Hhayi nje "kufanele aguquke" — kufanele acabange lokhu njengokusemandla. Izinto zocwaningo zomthombo, amadokhumenti ezomthetho, nocwaningo olubucayi akufanele luphile kunoma yimuphi umhlinzeki ongalufunda. Proton Drive ngephasiwedi eqinile, kanye ne-backup yendawo ekudrayvini yangaphandle ebethelwe, kuyisisekelo.
Izikhahlamezi zokufuduka ezifanele ukwazi
Amafayela awabelanwe nawe awazikhiphi kahle. Google Takeout ihlanganisa kuphela amafayela oziphethe. Amafayela abanye abantu ababelane nawo kuwe adinga ukudownloadwa ngokukodwa noma aphinde abelanwe ngu mnikazi. Lokhu yingxenye enkulu yokudonsa lapho kufuduka khona.
Ukuhleleka kwe-Google Photos akusapheli. Uma ikhonti lakho le-Google linezithombe ezinama-album aklezifiso, ama-tag obuso, nezinkumbulo ezenziwe nge-AI, lokho konke kung-metadata yomkhiqizo wezithombe — hhayi okuqukethwe kwefayela kangempela. Lapho usisa amafayela ku-Proton Drive, ulahlekelwa isendlalelo sokuhlukaniswa. Hlela isu lokuhlela izithombe elihlukile (ikhatheloghe yendawo ye-Lightroom, insizakalo yokusingatha izithombe ehlukile njenge-Ente noma i-Immich ezizisebenzela).
Ukuguqulwa kwamafayela ehofisi. Uma une-Google Docs (ifomethi yendabuko), aweyona amafayela aphathekayo — ayifomethi yabumba ka-Google esebenza ngaphakathi kwe-Google Docs kuphela. Takeout izikhipha njenge-.docx / .xlsx ngokuzenzakalela, Proton Docs engawavula kodwa engalahlekelwa ukuhlukaniswa. Buyekeza idokhumenti ngayinye eguquliwe ngaphambi kokususa okokusekuqaleni ka-Google.
Amadrayivi awabelanwayo ku-Workspace. Uma ukuhlanganyela le-Workspace, "Amadrayivi Awabelanwayo" (amafayela aphethwe inhlangano, hhayi wena) awazikhiphi nge-Takeout yomuntu siqu. Uzodinga ukubandakanyeka komphathi wehlangano.
Into enye eyengeziwe — Proton Drive akuyona indlela eyodwa
Lesi sihloko sigxile ku-Proton Drive ngoba kuyinketho yabathengi eyethandwa kakhulu ebethelwe kwe-end-to-end. Kufanele wazi izinye izindlela uma Proton ingafezeki:
- Tresorit — Swiss, E2E encrypted, kugxile kwinkampani. Kubiza kakhulu kune-Proton, izici zomphathi weqembu ezikhudlwana.
- Sync.com — Canadian, E2E encrypted, izintengo eziphikisanayo, ukubonwa komakhi kwencane.
- pCloud nge-Crypto add-on — Swiss, ukubethela kwe-E2E kuyisithuthuko esikhokhelwayo phezu kwecebo elijwayelekile elikhokhelwayo. Kungaba nesivumelwano sezindleko ekuthengeni okukodwa okuphila kude.
- iCloud Drive ngoku-Advanced Data Protection — Uhlelo lwe-Apple, E2E lweDrive, Photos, Notes, Backup.
- Kuzisebenzela — Nextcloud, Seafile, noma OwnCloud ku-VPS noma i-home NAS. Ubumfihlo obukhulu, umthwalo omkhulu wokunakekelwa.
Bona esinye isitoreji samafayela abethelwe esijulile sokuthi uqhathanise Proton Drive vs Tresorit vs Sync.com.
Okuhlobene
- Ukubuyekezwa kwe-Proton Drive — ukujuluka okuzimele
- Ukuqhathanisa kwesitoreji samafayela abethelwe — umbono obanzi womhlinzeki-maningi
- I-email ebethelwe — Proton Mail, Tutanota, Mailbox.org
- Uhlu Lokuhlola Lobumfihlo — ukuhlolwa kwezinyathelo ezingama-20 zamakhonti akho
- Ukuqhathanisa kobumfihlo be-OS ye-desktop — i-OS lapho isitoreji sakho semafu sisebenza khona nasibalulekile